You can work for both Shipt and Instacart at the same time, as there is no conflict working for both. Pay is comparable, with Shipt paying shoppers $16 to $22 an hour and Instacart shoppers making up to $17 an hour. Pay depends on your location and the number of orders you take.
Earnings and Tips
Tips can significantly supplement your Shipt earnings, potentially bringing your salary to over $15 per hour. Completing several Shipt orders simultaneously could raise your earnings to $25 per hour. Conversely, Instacart guarantees at least $5 per delivery and $7 to $10 per full-service order. Customers often tip Shipt shoppers 20% for exceptional service or long distances, and 100% of these tips go directly to the shopper.
Company Benefits and Coverage
Shipt offers benefits like more affordable insurance and prescriptions, whereas Instacart provides local store discounts and financial wellness assistance. In terms of coverage, Instacart has a larger footprint, operating in all 50 states and Canada, which may result in more available orders, especially for those residing in the suburbs. The platform also boasts more store partnerships and locations.
Instacart differentiates itself with better order tracking, even though customers can communicate with shoppers using both services.
Pay Comparisons
Although Shipt drivers generally earn 18% more per hour, Instacart drivers receive 8% more per delivery. By working for both Shipt and Instacart, you can maximize your earning potential. As an independent contractor, you have the freedom to choose which platform you want to work for based on the comparative pay and tips in your area.
Tax Obligations and Payment Schedules
Shipt does not cover gas costs, but it partners with Upside to offer cashback on gas purchases, and they may provide bonuses during busy times. However, as an independent contractor, you are responsible for handling your own tax payments. Shipt provides tax forms to those who cross a certain earning threshold.
Payments from Shipt are made weekly each Friday for work completed the prior week, with instant withdrawal options available, though fees may apply. In larger cities, earnings through Shipt can range between $20 to $30 an hour, but smaller areas might see averages closer to $15 per hour, not including tips.